The Problem With the "No Thank You Bite"

We all want our kids to try new foods. I mean, let's be real. It's soooo frustrating when they say "I don't like it" when they've never even tried it.

So a "no thank you bite" seems like the perfect solution:

You don't have to eat it, but you have to try it.

Just one bite, and then you can say no thank you.

It's low-stakes, it comes from the best intentions, and they might even like it. So why not do a "no thank you bite"?

I got this question twice from clients in the same week, so I know you might be wondering about it too. In this episode, I break down what the no thank you bite actually does at the table, what the research says about pressure and kids' eating, and why the concept itself isn't the problem.

In this episode, we talk about:

• What the no thank you bite is (and why so many well-meaning parents use it)
• The "finish your soup" study, and what it tells us about pressure at the table
• The real difference between a rule and an invitation
• Three paths forward depending on what's happening at your table right now
• Exactly what to do if you've been enforcing the bite and want to change the rules

If you've ever sat at the table wondering whether making your kid take that one bite is helping or hurting, this episode will give you a clear answer and a next step you can use tonight.

✅ Research: "Finish your soup": Counterproductive effects of pressuring children to eat on intake and affect (Galloway et al., 2006, Appetite)

CONNECT with Nicole:

FREE Training: Raise a Balanced Eater AND Protect Their Relationship With Food

- Instagram: @nicolecruzRD

SUBSCRIBE & REVIEW:

If you loved this episode, it would mean so much for you to follow, subscribe, share, or leave a review.

Your support helps us reach more conscious and loving parents who need these insight!

Thank you for tuning in and see you next week!

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:01

Welcome to the Intentional Table Podcast. This is where we go beyond nutrition to not only talk about how to help your child eat well and get the nutrients they need, but how to also support them in having a healthy relationship with food. If you want your child to eat a variety, listen to their body cues, eat the amount they need, and not be obsessed with sweets or any food. Or you just don't want to fight about food, you're in the right place. Here you'll find practical tips and compassionate guidance to support your family in navigating food with more joy and less stress. I'm Nicole Cruz, registered dietitian and mom of three, and I can't wait to dive in to today's episode with you. Welcome back to the intentional table. So I got this question twice in the last week from clients, and I know that if they have this question, you probably do too. So the question is: what do you think about doing a no thank you bite? Now, if you've never heard the term a no thank you bite, let me give you a quick rundown. Some people might call it a one bite rule or a polite bite. And essentially what it means is that you have to try the food, but then you can say no thank you. So whatever's out on the table, everybody has to take at least one bite. And after that one bite, you can certainly say no thank you if you don't want it anymore. But you have to try it. And the purpose is to encourage kids to try new things. And that's fantastic. That's absolutely what we want to be doing, encouraging our kids to eat a variety of foods, to expand their palate, to try something and see if they like it. Because the truth is, and this is what we often feel as parents, is how can they say they don't like it if they've never tried it? And sometimes they do take that bite and realize, oh, I do like this. This is good. I want more. But that doesn't always happen. And here's the flip side. Even though it's coming from the most positive place and with such good intentions to our kids, it still feels like pressure. They feel that sense of this is what I have to do, this is what I'm supposed to eat. And it can create power struggles and standoffs at the table, especially if you have a child who's more strong-willed and doesn't want to eat it. And now we just have a battle. And we know from research that pressure at the table backfires. There's a well-known study where researchers repeatedly told preschoolers to finish their soup. And those kids ate less. They complained more about the food. And even later, when no one was pressuring them anymore, they still ate less than the kids who'd never been pressured. So pressure doesn't just not help in the moment. It actually teaches kids to like the food less long term. And that's because a rule like the no thank you bite doesn't let our kids explore new foods in their own time. It doesn't create that genuine curiosity. And it's that curiosity that leads to real long-term enjoyment of foods. Instead, when we do something like the no thank you bite, trying food starts to feel like a chore rather than something that could be fun or exciting. And as I always say, it's really not about the two bites of broccoli tonight. It's how our kids are feeling about broccoli when they are 20, 30, 40 years old. Are they still wanting to eat it? Yes, we're feeding for now, but ultimately we're feeding for the future. And that's exactly what another study showed: that young adults reported that the foods they were pressured to eat as children, they still disliked as adults. So the no thank you bite isn't actually creating that love of vegetables or protein that we're hoping for. It's creating more resistance and potentially an adult who never wants to touch those foods. And even beyond all of that, I think we have to remember that the way we feed our kids is about more than just food. Our goal is to build trust and autonomy around food, yes, but also trust and autonomy in general. And food is one of the places we're instilling this in our children so that they carry it into other areas of their life as well. Now, I'm not entirely against a no thank you bite. The concept itself can genuinely be helpful. The concept isn't the issue. It's when it becomes a rule. So when we treat the no thank you bite as something fun, like it's an invitation, it can create curiosity, it can make food feel a little bit exciting, it can help our kids feel brave and empowered when they are the ones choosing to take that no thank you bite. And it can create a sense of safety, like I get to try it, and I can say no thank you. I can even spit it out if I don't like it. I can try it again another time if I want. But that's different than having a rule where everyone needs to try it. So we really need to ask ourselves: is the no thank you bite being framed in a way where they can also say, no, I don't want to take a no thank you bite? Or does it feel like something they have to do? Because that's the difference. Is this something that our kids get to do and they might find fun, or something that they have to do? So, what should you do now? Depending on what's happening at your table right now, here's what I'd recommend. Path one. If you've never required a no thank you bite, you can introduce this concept as something fun if you want. You might say, Do you want to take a no thank you bite? You can just try it. And if you don't like it, you can say no, thank you. And maybe you'll end up loving it. And if they say, no, I don't want to, you can say, no problem. You don't have to. You don't have to eat anything you don't want. We're just offering it as an invitation, not a rule. And over time, it can become part of how your family talks about food. In our house, everyone knows that a no thank you bite means you can try something and say, no, thank you. I don't want to have it. And that's okay. You're allowed to not like things, to not want to eat them, but nobody has to eat it. Now, path two is for you. If this is something that you've been doing, you've been requiring that bite and you've been enforcing it. Now you have two options here. The first is that you just stop doing it. You stop saying they have to try a bite, and your family kind of moves along and nobody says too much about it. And if your kids ask, Do I have to try it when they're at the table? You can simply say, No, you're welcome to take a bite if you want to, but you don't have to try anything. And the second option is to actually introduce the way that you're going to be handling food from now on. So you might say something like, I know in the past we've had everyone try a bite of the food that we put out. And as we've been thinking more about how we want food to feel in our home, we've decided that nobody has to take a bite if they don't want to. We'd love it if you still want to try new things. And it's okay if you need more time or you're just not interested in it tonight. And then there's a third path. And this is for you if there have already been lots of power struggles around food. And if that's the case, we definitely don't want to introduce a no-thank you bite at all, or for our kids to feel any sort of pressure to try anything. So you simply want to put the food out for dinner or whatever the meal or snack is and not say anything about it. We don't want to comment on the food, ask if they want to try it, or even point out anything new or different. Even things that sound encouraging, like, just try it, you'll like it, will feel like pressure right now. So once we've removed all of that pressure and once the table feels more relaxed and enjoyable and we've created a sense of safety, then it's okay to say something like, oh, these green beans have a new sauce. Do you think you might want to try them? As long as it's absolutely okay if they say, no, I don't want any. Because for kids who have felt pressure in the past, even gentle nudges like talking about how the food tastes good or that they might like it, can feel like more pressure and create more resistance. So tonight, as you sit down for dinner, I want to encourage you to think about where your family is with food right now. Has there been pressure? Have you been doing a no, thank you bite? How does the table feel? And then consider which path might be the next best step for you. This isn't something that needs weeks of planning out and figuring out. It's a really small and simple idea, concept, thing that you can implement. And if you're ready, you can just start tonight. You can start to do it different, or you can introduce the concept as something that might be fun and exciting so that your child feels empowered and encouraged if they want to try it. Because ultimately, that's the whole goal with food: for our kids to feel safe, to feel trusted, to feel confident, to feel curious, and to feel empowered. So now, let's take a moment and remind ourselves, as we always do, that nourishing a healthy relationship with food is just as important, if not more, than the food itself. Thank you for joining me at the Intentional Table, and I'll see you next time.